CHANCELLOR BURIES STONEHENGE TUNNEL VISION

Date:

Share post:

thePipeLine looks at reaction to the cancellation by UK Chancellor Rachel Reeves of the contentious A303 Stonehenge tunnel and dual carriageway project which has divided UK Archaeology.

What goes around comes around and following then New Labour Chancellor Gordon Brown cancelling an earlier iteration of a Stonehenge Tunnel on the A303 in 2007, in 2024 it has fallen to the new Labour Chancellor Rachel Reeves to bury the latest plan to resolve the issue of traffic on the principle route to West Country and incidentally to remove the road from the immediate vicinity of the famous prehistoric stones thereby enhancing their
heritage value.  Or was it the other way round?

There was an initial hesitation to finally bury the hopes of Highways England that its often challenged tunnel and dual carriageway scheme on the Stonehenge and Avebury World Heritage Site would actually break ground.

- Advertisement -

Ms Reeves statement to Parliament only included the phrase that the Transport Secretary had agreed not to “take forward” the A303 Stonehenge Tunnel project, leaving open the possibility that the project might be taken forward at some point in the future.

However, within minutes a document with the very Government messaging title of “Fixing the foundations: public spending audit 2024-25” dropped on the Treasury website providing confirmation that the Government was indeed cancelling the £1.7 billion plus scheme, consigning it to the twilight zone of abandoned Government projects, including the forty new hospitals which never were and most of HS2, with the damning verdict that it was of “low value” and “unaffordable”.

The Stonehenge Alliance, members of which had been in the High Court only days before as part of the Save Stonehenge World Heritage Site bid to have the development consent order for the A303 project overturned, were quick to welcome what was an apparent affirmation of years of campaigning.

Chair of the Alliance, John Adams said,

- Advertisement -

“This is a vindication of all the work of so many people over so many years from supporters around the world.” adding,

“National Highways’ misguided project was called out for what it was: low value and unaffordable. It was also highly damaging.”

Adding a conciliatory note Mr Adams acknowledged the genuine issues of traffic management in the local area which remain an issue, Mr Adams continued,

“Now that it has been scrapped, we need to move on. As soon as the budget is there, we need to ensure, as a priority, that local traffic is better
managed and rail access to the South West improved.”

However, the Councillor Richard Clewer, the Leader of Conservative controlled Wiltshire Council, which was strongly supportive of the project, was in no mood to be magnanimous.

“We are extremely dismayed and disappointed at the Government’s decision to cancel the A303 Stonehenge tunnel project.” Cllr Clewer said in a press release,
adding,

“These improvements are needed now to ease traffic congestion on the A303 and reduce traffic in our communities, and also ensure economic growth in Wiltshire, unlocking jobs and investment in the wider south-west region.”

“It has taken many years of lobbying and working closely with partners, including National Highways, to bring this major infrastructure project to Wiltshire, and so it is a huge blow to get to the stage when construction is ready to begin, only to have this taken away from us at this late hour.”

Cllr Clewer observed,

“There has already been £160m spent on this project, and cancelling it now wastes that huge investment, including the work to run a power supply up the A360 to the tunnel site.”

To critics of the scheme Cllr Clewer did not explain why, if the scheme was always unaffordable, National Highways had continued to issue contracts and
carry out enabling works, including that multi -million programme of work by Scottish and Southern Electricity Networks (SSEN) to install high voltage and fibre optic cables for the construction phase of the project which would not now be needed, and which involved three months of disruption to local traffic.

Then, after taking a few days to consider its position Chief Executive Duncan Wilson, issued a terse three paragraph statement expressing the disappointment of historic environment regulator Historic England that the project had been cancelled, and satisfaction that UNESCO had not placed the World Heritage Site on its list of sites in danger and concluding,

“We remain hopeful that at some point in the future, this scheme could be reconsidered as the best option to solve the longstanding traffic issues around Stonehenge and reunite this internationally important prehistoric landscape.” Mr Wilson said.

However, critics of the scheme were quick to point out that Mr Wilson’s opinion that the current scheme was the “best option” for the World Heritage Site was not reflected in the opinions of the many independent archaeological, environmental and transport experts who had spoken out against the scheme. Not least the Government’s own independent planning inspectorate which, after an exhaustive review of the evidence relating to the project in 2020, concluded that the project would introduce,

“…a greater physical change to the Stonehenge landscape than has occurred in its 6,000 years as a place of widely acknowledged human significance.”

and therefore the project should not be given the go ahead because,

“The effect of the Proposed Development on the OUV of the WHS would lead to substantial harm to the significance of the designated heritage asset. In addition, there would be considerable harm to landscape character and visual amenity.”

Meanwhile National Highways itself, the body running the project has not updated the project webpages to tell readers of the cancellation and the body made no comment on its A303 Stonehenge account on X-Twitter.

As of the time of publication the most recent comment was dated 21 June wishing everyone a happy Summer Solstice.

Of course, projects are carried out by people and many archaeologists responding on Social Media expressed concern at their colleagues who might not now have work going forward on account of the cancellation.

It was announced with great fanfare in October 2020 that the project had awarded a contract to the value of £35 million for archaeological work on the A303 Stonehenge project. However, at the time of publication Wessex Archaeology have not made any public comment on the cancellation, nor on any potential impact on the company’s cash flow and staffing.

However, in speaking for the wider construction sector the director of operations of the Civil Engineering Contractors Association (CECA) Marie-Claude Hemming might also have been speaking for archaeological contractors when she told the New Civil Engineer website,

“The Chancellor’s announcements are disappointing but will not come as a shock to industry, not least because a shortfall in funding for public projects has been evident for some time.”

Asking that the Government engage with the sector in an effort to move schemes to delivery, she added,

“…it is frustrating that firms are expected to bear the costs of delay without regard to their forward planning in terms of workload and skills.”

Of the sector bodies representing archaeologists which might be expected to comment given the implications of Chancellor Reeve’s decision for jobs and unit incomes and cash flows, the Chartered Institute for Archaeologists have made no direct comment, although the organisation did flag up the consultation on proposed changes to the National Planning Policy Framework also announced this week, while the Federation of Archaeological Managers and Employers [FAME] appear to have made no comment, either on their website, or social media platforms.

The Council for British Archaeology, which along with other archaeological bodies had opposed some aspects of the A303 project and sought to bring about changes, appears also to have made no direct comment about the cancellation of the Stonehenge project.

It was left to one of the UK’s oldest campaigning groups to publish what is probably the most nuanced response to the Government’s decision encompassing both the economic and archaeological politics of the controversy.

On 30 July RESCUE, the British Archaeology Trust welcomed the cancellation of the A303 project and in doing so admitted some home truths.

“The Stonehenge World Heritage Site is almost certainly this country’s most significant archaeological site.” RESCUE said, stating the obvious, adding,

“The dialogue around this proposed infrastructure project has polarised opinion and divided a number of communities – not the least of which is our own archaeological discipline.”

RESCUE continued acknowledging the Government’s framing that the cancellation of the project was actually in the cause of promoting the growth the Starmer Government sees as crucial to the country’s and its own, success,

“Of crucial concern has been the years of damaging discourse that has pitched the historic environment and those that seek to protect it, as being in opposition to the economic progress of the country.” RESCUE said, admitting that “The arguments both for and against the project were far more nuanced than this discourse allowed and brought many organisations with competing interests into conflict.”

“We sincerely hope that yesterday’s announcement can bring an end to this.” RESCUE concluded.

RESCUE’s view of the project itself was damning,

“Rescue firmly believes that the historic environment can and should be a key driver to sensitive and well-considered design and development.” the organisation said.

“Unfortunately no iteration of the Stonehenge scheme embraced these principles.”

“We were presented with a succession of poorly-envisaged and increasingly penny-pinching and ill-conceived schemes which whilst respecting the core of the Stonehenge site, failed to properly address the surrounding landscape of which the stone circle is only a part.”

The press release concluded with a look to the future.

Acknowledging that,

“Recent archaeological works associated with this project have been conducted with skill and integrity, and have produced results which prove the
wider landscape is of paramount importance.”

RESCUE concluded,

“We look forward to not only seeing these results published in full, but also, and hopefully, seeing them kickstart a new dawn for research into this hugely significant archaeological inheritance.”

For many archaeologists this is a crucial point.

In the same way that the cancellation by Chancellor Reeves of the A303 Stonehenge tunnel and upgrade was nothing to do with archaeology and everything to do with politics and economic policy, the ending of the tunnel project, at least in its current iteration, does not mean the end of archaeology within the Stonehenge and Avebury World Heritage Site.

All that has happened is that a concentrated programme, at the locations and to the timetable of a transport infrastructure project is now off the table, at least for the time being.

Archaeologists are free to develop other research driven projects, perhaps drawing on the work done for National Highways during the development of the project, or perhaps not.

Meanwhile as might be expected from a UN body, at UNESCO there was no sign of schadenfreude in the diplomatic response of Director General Audrey Azouley.

“@UNESCO welcomes the Starmer government’s decision to cancel the construction of a road tunnel under the #Stonehenge World Heritage Site.
UNESCO stands ready to support the UK authorities in reconciling the needs of development and conservation of this outstanding heritage.”  She stated on X-Twitter.

As with RESCUE’s response, and that of many in the heritage world, there is the implicit expectation that the desire for development in a rapidly changing world mean that this is unlikely to be the end of the story of the attempt to dig a tunnel under the Stonehenge landscape and bury the A303 and its undoubted traffic problems.

On a positive note it can be suggested that the breathing space brought about by Chancellor Rachel Reeve’s financial decision to cancel the current iteration of the A303 project offers the opportunity for the archaeological world, the Stonehenge Alliance, and other stakeholders, not least people in the local community, to work together to identify and campaign for an acceptable alternative to what Highways England had offered. An alternative everyone can get behind, such as the long tunnel or an alternative surface route which avoid damage to the World Heritage Site entirely.

Hopefully another lesson will have been learned also by the archaeological world.

That is not let itself be suckered into supporting a major Government infrastructure project by the promise of questionable heritage benefits, possibly career defining research opportunities and very large contracts, based on nothing more than the promises and the sometimes unlawful manipulations of process, by cynical politicians with an agenda, few scruples and no money.

 

 

 

 

thePipeLine is free to read and we promise it always will be, but researching the kind of story you have just read costs time and money.

If you think it is important that archaeology and heritage has an independent voice speaking truth to power please buy us a Ko-fi

And you can support the #WatchingBrief on YouTube and Tik Tok via PATREON from just £1 per month.

 

 

 

- Advertisement -

Share post:

thePipeLine
thePipeLine
thePipeLine is an independent news publication that investigates the place that heritage, politics, and money meet.

1 COMMENT

  1. The best thing that ever happened! Stonehenge is the most important and popular Ancient Monument we have in the UK. The road, like HS2, was just another “vanity project” that cost millions of tax payers money just to satisfy the motorists insatiable demand for more roads, when it should be spent on creating less traffic!

    James

Comments are closed.

spot_img
spot_img

Related articles

GRAHAM HANCOCK- A LIFE [NOT] IN ARCHAEOLOGY: A NEW ARCHAEOSOUP PODCAST SERIES

Follow the rest of the series, Graham Hancock:  A Life In Archaeology on the Archaeosoup YouTube Channel Andy...

AN OPEN LETTER TO ANDY BURNHAM: AN ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE HUT OF THE NORTH [AND THE REST OF THE COUNTRY]

Dear Prime Minister, In 2026 the annual Festival of British Archaeology, when the Council for British Archaeology celebrates...

EX EDITORS STAND BY INTERVIEW AS EAA EXECUTIVE BOARD RESPONDS TO CRITICISM OVER HANDLING OF GAZA POLICY

Dr Zena Kamash and Dr Marianne Moen, have told thePipeLine that they stand by their account of the...

TIMELINE OF GAZA TERMOIL AS EDITORS RESIGN AT THE EUROPEAN ASSOCIATION OF ARCHAEOLOGISTS

The Israel/Palestine conflict is one of the longest running and most intractible human rights and social justice issues...